Vicar in attack on mourner tributes
A LEADING Tunbridge Wells clergyman has been branded "insensitive" after unleashing a scathing attack on modern funerals.
Father Ed Tomlinson, of St Barnabas' Church, Quarry Road, said he had better ways of spending his time than at crematorium services where the dead were "led in by the tunes of Tina Turner...and sent into the furnace with 'I Did It My Way' blaring out across the speakers".
-

CONTROVERSY: Father Ed Tomlinson at St Barnabas' Church in Tunbridge Wells PV2701085/13
The vicar whose blogsite rants attract a cult following, said the widespread fashion for "a poem from nan combined with a saccharine message from a pop star before being popped in the oven" left him feeling like an unwanted guest at many funerals.
He added: "I have... stood at the 'crem' like a lemon, wondering why on earth I am present."
But Denise Cantor-Kaydar of CRUSE Bereavement Care, which offers advice and support to anyone affected by a death, criticised the holy man's rant.
"These remarks are pretty insensitive," she said.
"Bereavement isn't funny. We all mourn in different ways and try to select the kind of burial the person would have wanted."
Mr Tomlinson, whose own Anglo-Catholic church offers full requiem mass with candles and incense, added: "Many families I have conducted funerals for have absolutely no desire for any Christian content whatsoever. To be brutally honest, I can think of a hundred better ways of spending my time as a priest."
Claiming modern ceremonies have been taken over by humanists and "ancient crumbling clerics" who will do whatever they are asked, Mr Tomlinson said: "Pastoral care is being left in the hands of those whose main aim is to make money."
However a spokesman for the British Humanist Association charity, which regularly conducts non-religious funerals in Tunbridge Wells, said: "Being funnelled into a ritual where you're saying goodbye to someone you've loved, in words you absolutely don't believe in is extremely painful."
Head of ceremonies Tana Wollen said: "People like the idea of celebrating life rather than committing to God."
Meanwhile undertaker Robert Hickmott, the sixth generation of the Grove Hill Road-based family firm said: "I think Father Ed is making a point. Non-religious funeral services are increasing and yes, people do choose Tina Turner, but a lot of families don't really know what they want."
Warning of the danger of funerals "declining into a collage of different bits," Canon Jim Stewart of St James' Church, in the parish adjoining St Barnabas', said: "I once led a service for a young woman which included so much of her favourite music that the family found it very hard to cope emotionally, and I don't think that's helpful."
Mr Tomlinson, whose 14-month-old blogsite has just topped 100,000 hits, said this week that he stood by his comments, warning: "The move away from Christianity has left people with a lack of choice. Life is slipping through their fingers."











20 Comments
View all
by John Saxton, Sevenoaks
Wednesday, October 21 2009, 1:32PM
“It's all part of the job. Everyone has the right to such a funeral, regardless. The following website deals with the matter nicely. www.bakewellchurch.co.uk/funerals”
by Jonathan Taylor, Totnes, Devon
Tuesday, October 20 2009, 8:21PM
“Postscript to the comment below: My apologies, Father Ed, for the mis-typing of your name; the worst thing a funeral celebrant or minister could have done!!”
by Jonathan Taylor, Totnes, Devon
Tuesday, October 20 2009, 8:16PM
“As an independent celebrant - trained by, but no longer practising with, the humanists, and with a wider view of spirituality and religion than they will bring to a funeral - I have to agree with Father Ted. If you listen, what he's actually saying is that those who opt for a minister of religion for the funeral of a loved one should do so consciously. If you want a ceremony that's meaningful to you and the person who has died, you need to think about what that means: a priest? An independent celebrant? Yourself? A friend? If you ask for a humanist, think about whether the person who died was actually a humanist. Most people END UP WITH a humanist funeral simply because they don't want a religious one, and they ask the Funeral Director, "what else is there?", and 'humanism' is the only answer they get.
Ask your funeral director what the choices are. And if you don't get a full answer, go on the web - believe me, there are plenty of choices, from pagans, atheists, spiritualists, independents, retired vicars who'll cooperate, self-taught people, you name it.
And if you're not up to the task, ask a friend to do it for you. Come to that, ask a friend to ring round a few Funeral Directors as well, to see which ones sound as if they'll feel right.
Don't roll over and accept what you're given. And don't ask a priest to compromise on his or her religion - I can't count the number of times a vicar, at a crematorium, has said to me: "I wish a lot more people would ask someone like you to conduct the service. I'm fed up with looking at a sea of hostile faces, all wishing I'd hurry up and get the God part out of the way."”
by Ros Curtis, Bucks
Tuesday, October 20 2009, 4:27PM
“Rev barry Tomlinson says -"The problem of the person taking a funeral not knowing the deceased is not confined to the Christian Minister. The humanist funeral taker will suffer the same problem." I'm afraid he is talking without any knowledge of how accredited Humanist Celebrants operate. We always visit families to discuss what they want and to learn about the person who has died, except where families don't want it, or where circmstances make it impossible. It's a shame he has no idea of how we operate.”
by brenda harper, Devon
Tuesday, October 20 2009, 3:16PM
“I totally agree with father Tomlinson. I have insisted in my will that I have a Christian funeral and I have also purchased my burial plot, because I do not believe in Christians being cremated. I want hymns and prayers and NO modern music.”